In the spring of 2025, Solon Mayor Edward Kraus told the Planning Commission that he and Councilman Bob Shimits had driven to Richfield and spent an entire afternoon at Michael Angelo's Winery. "We saw the love that these people put into their business," he said, as cleveland.com reported, "the inside, the outside, the vineyards going across the street." The mayor wasn't the only one who made the drive. Council members, residents who supported the project and residents who opposed it all visited, and they all came back to Solon meetings and described what they had seen.
A year after the vote, that habit of comparison is the most useful way to read the empty field at 37500 Aurora Road. Solon has already seen its winery, in Richfield and on the 2025 site plan. The city measured the project against Richfield, and the zoning voters approved tells Planning Commission and Council to weigh the final site plan against the one shown during the rezoning. The months since the vote have gone to planning and document review.
Last November's Vote, and This Year's Quiet
Issue 33 passed on Nov. 4, 2025. According to final unofficial Cuyahoga County Board of Elections results reported by the Cleveland Jewish News, 4,515 voters, or 73.4%, approved the zoning amendment and 1,637 voted against it. Under Solon's ward veto system, the measure also had to pass in Ward 1, where the property sits. Chagrin Valley Today reported the Ward 1 count as 696 for and 389 against.
Since then, the site has been quiet. In his Summer 2026 newsletter, Ward 6 Councilman Bob Shimits wrote that brothers Michael and Matthew Ciocca, owners of Michael Angelo's Winery and Bakery in Richfield, are planning a similar concept in Solon and were "going through the planning and development stages." The Fall 2026 Ward 7 newsletter from Councilman Brian Laubscher adds a little more. The developers are preparing and completing documents for review by city engineers and the Planning Department, and the project still has to meet all city planning and zoning requirements, including required documents and studies.
The vote approved the zoning amendment. The project remains in planning and document review.
The Old Schultz Farm Behind the Ballot Language
The ballot language described a parcel number. Neighbors know the place as the former Schultz Farm, which TMMC Ohio LLC, the Ciocca brothers' company, bought with the goal of building a winery, restaurant, bakery and event center. According to the city's April 7, 2025 planning memo, the project parcel covers 24.23 acres. Before the vote it was zoned R-1-D single-family residential, and voters moved it into a new W-1 Winery District created for this project.
The ballot measure that passed was the second version of the project. In September 2024 the Cioccas filed an application to rezone two parcels for a winery with attached townhomes. Planning Commission recommended it, and Council held two readings before the application was withdrawn on Dec. 16, 2024. A new application followed on March 3, 2025, this time for a single parcel with no residential component. The second parcel, 7.83 acres, kept its R-1-D residential zoning.
Planning Commission voted unanimously to send the revised plan to City Council after an April 29, 2025 public hearing. Council put it on the ballot at its June 16, 2025 meeting. As cleveland.com explained before the vote, Solon's charter requires zoning changes outside the central retail district to be approved by both Council and voters, which is why the decision ended up at the polls.
Richfield Set the Scale
The city's own analysis uses the same benchmark the mayor did. The planning memo says the Solon winery's operational scale and intensity will be similar to the Richfield winery, which has operated since summer 2018:
"The Richfield winery is located on a 13-acre site, while the proposed Solon location will occupy 24.23 acres, making it approximately 86.4% larger. Despite the larger site, the land use intensity and operational scale will remain consistent with the Richfield facility."
The extra acreage goes mostly to grapes. The Cioccas have said a full 60% of the Solon property will grow grapes, which continues the Schultz Farm's agricultural use. Richfield also shows the kind of business Solon is getting. The winery's own description of the Richfield location lists seasonal full-menu dining, wine flights, patios with vineyard views, bakery desserts and private events. At a pre-election open house, Michael Ciocca said the family wanted Solon residents to have a new place for bridal and baby showers, birthday parties and work events, all of which are popular in Richfield.
The bakery side of the business is older than the winery. Michael Angelo's has run a bakery in Broadview Heights since 2000 and added the Richfield winery in 2018.
What the 2025 Plan Puts on Paper
Neighbors in the Woodlands subdivision, which borders the site, raised concerns about traffic, noise, lighting and how a commercial event venue fits beside single-family homes. Those concerns shaped the second version of the plan. Supporters pointed to new dining, jobs and tax revenue for the city. The plan Planning Commission reviewed in 2025 includes:
- Access: vehicles enter and leave from Aurora Road on dedicated one-way drives, one in and one out.
- Screening: a four-foot landscaped mound with evergreen plantings beside all parking areas and along parts of the main building that don't face the vineyard.
- Parking and drainage: parking moved to reduce the impact on neighbors, and the drainage pond moved from near the main building to the western edge of the vineyard.
- Setbacks and footprint: all buildings at least 100 feet from the western property line, and a building footprint nearly 20,000 square feet smaller than the 2024 concept.
- Sound: event rooms for private gatherings, with no loud outdoor music allowed.
- Studies: the applicant committed to meet the city's traffic study requirements and to build any improvements the study recommends, including work in the public right-of-way.
As a city official told cleveland.com, the winery goes through multiple layers of review and inspection, with stormwater and drainage control monitored by the city's engineering department and liquor licensing handled under Ohio law.
The Clause That Ties the Review to 2025
One provision in the W-1 district rules connects the 2025 site plan to the final review. Ordinance No. 2025-093, passed June 16, 2025, sends winery projects through Solon's standard site plan review. When a rezoning was part of the process, as it was here, the ordinance adds that the Planning Commission, in making its recommendation, and City Council, in approving or denying a site plan, "shall take into consideration whether the proposed site plan is generally consistent with the site plan provided by the applicant during the zone change process."
The city's planning memo described the idea behind this as making outcomes more predictable for the city and for surrounding property owners. The ordinance also lets the City of Solon require a development agreement for any project in the W-1 district. The mounds, setbacks and drive layout were shown at the 2025 hearings and at the October open house at Grantwood Golf Course.
The 1837 House by the Road
One part of the site's future is still being worked out. The historic Samuel Bull residence, built in 1837, sits near Aurora Road between the planned entry and exit drives. The city's memo calls it one of the area's earliest homesteads, though it has been modified and expanded over the years. In their application, the Cioccas said they were willing to work with the Solon Historical Society and the City of Solon on ways to preserve the site's historical significance connected to the house.
The house stands where Aurora Road traffic will turn in, so it will be the first thing visitors see. Anyone who wants to see the rest of the project before Solon's version takes shape can drive to 5515 Broadview Road in Richfield, the address the mayor, several council members and residents on both sides of the issue visited in 2025.
Projects like this one affect the homes around them, from sightlines and traffic patterns to the questions buyers ask about Aurora Road. If you own near the old Schultz Farm and want to talk through how a project still in review affects your own plans, Smith Garofoli Group follows these approvals closely and is glad to walk you through it. Contact Us.