In a Window on Main Street column, the editors of the Chagrin Valley Times wrote about a magazine feature that held up a historic home on Chagrin Road as its example of Chagrin Falls charm. Their reply called the house lovely and pointed out that it sits in Bainbridge Township, in Geauga County, not in the Village of Chagrin Falls, which is in Cuyahoga County.
Their explanation was the post office. The column said the U.S. Postal Service long ago put the farms and open land around the village on one postal route named "Chagrin Falls." Residents of the village and of Bainbridge still share a post office building in the village.
Buyers run into the same thing every time they scroll listings. "Chagrin Falls" on a listing tells you which post office handles the mail. It doesn't tell you which market the house trades in. The village itself sits near the middle of the local price range. The homes that sell for close to double are in the villages and the township on its Cuyahoga side, and those, too, carry a Chagrin Falls address.
Two ZIP Codes, Two Counties, Several Governments
The Chagrin Valley Times column gave the village ZIP code 44022 and Bainbridge 44023. It added that other towns next to Chagrin Falls, in both counties, share the Chagrin Falls postal name and ZIP. A ZIP-to-county directory puts 44022 with Bentleyville, Chagrin Falls and Moreland Hills in Cuyahoga County, and 44023 with Auburn Township and Chagrin Falls in Geauga County. The county's deed records show the same thing. Bainbridge Township homes that changed hands in October 2026 are listed with mailing addresses reading "Chagrin Falls OH 44023."
The places behind those ZIP codes are very different in size. The column described the village as about 2 square miles with roughly 4,000 residents and a mayor-and-council government. Bainbridge, by the same account, covered 25 square miles with about 11,500 residents and was run by a board of township trustees, with its own police, fire department and historical society museum.
The school map doesn't follow the postal name either. The column said most Bainbridge children attend the Kenston Local School District. The Chagrin Falls Exempted Village School District serves the village, South Russell, Bentleyville and a small part of Moreland Hills. South Russell's village website also names Chagrin Falls Exempted Village Schools as its district. South Russell is its own Geauga County village, bordered by Chagrin Falls, Newbury, Russell and Bainbridge.
The Village Sits in the Middle of the Price Range
The Village of Chagrin Falls is the place most buyers have in mind when they search the name. It is also the most active market under that name. A cleveland.com analysis of Cuyahoga County property records, published January 6, 2026, put the village's 2025 median sale price at $532,500 across 84 sales. In 2024 it was $540,000 across 65 sales. The analysis left out multi-parcel sales, sales under $10,000 and sheriff's deeds.
Prices rise in the Cuyahoga County communities around the village. The same 2025 figures show:
- Moreland Hills: $615,000 median on 42 sales
- Bentleyville: $995,000 on five sales
- Chagrin Falls Township: $1,187,500 on two sales
Some of those counts are very small. Bentleyville's median came from five sales in 2025 and seven in 2024, when it was $1,050,000. The township's came from two. A median built on a handful of closings can move a long way when one estate trades. Still, both years point the same way: Bentleyville and the township are a different price band from the village.
The Geauga side lands close to the village. The Geauga County Auditor's October 2026 transfer report lists each recorded deed. We counted only valid residential sales of homes, leaving out land-only sales. On that basis, Bainbridge Township had 12 sales in October with a median of $543,000. Auburn Township had five, with a median of $500,000. South Russell had five, with a median of $540,000.
These are figures from one month, not a year, and they come from deed dates, not MLS closings. Even so, Bainbridge's October median came within about $10,000 of the village's 2025 figure. So the mix-up in the Times column was more than a matter of names. In price, the village and Bainbridge are close to each other. Moreland Hills is a step above, and Bentleyville and Chagrin Falls Township are a long way above.
The Same Address, Side by Side
The table puts each community's most recent median from above next to its published residential property tax rate and its 2026 municipal income tax rate, each with its date.
| Community | County | Median sale price and period | Residential property tax | Municipal income tax, 2026 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Village of Chagrin Falls | Cuyahoga | $532,500, 2025 | 2.13% of market value, tax year 2025 | 1.85% |
| Moreland Hills | Cuyahoga | $615,000, 2025 | 2.27% Chagrin Falls school portion; 1.98% Orange school portion | 1.00% |
| Bentleyville | Cuyahoga | $995,000, 2025 | 2.14% of market value, tax year 2025 | 1.00% |
| Chagrin Falls Township | Cuyahoga | $1,187,500, 2025 | 1.97% of market value, tax year 2025 | None |
| Bainbridge Township | Geauga | $543,000, October 2026 | 60.19 effective mills, Kenston portion, tax year 2025 | None |
| Auburn Township | Geauga | $500,000, October 2026 | Set by Geauga County district | None |
| South Russell | Geauga | $540,000, October 2026 | Set by Geauga County district | 1.25% |
The Cuyahoga percentages come from the county's "Rates of Taxation for Tax Year 2025 Due in 2026" chart. That chart lists the village at $67.40 per $1,000 of taxable value and Chagrin Falls Township at $62.17.
The same chart has two rows for Moreland Hills: "Moreland Hills/Chagrin Fall" at 2.27% of market value and "Moreland Hills/Orange" at 1.98%.
In Geauga County, the tax year 2025 figure for the Bainbridge Township–Kenston district is 60.19 effective mills, paid in 2026. The state's estimate for an owner-occupied home valued at $100,000 is $1,884 a year. Rates for other Geauga districts are published by the Geauga County Auditor.
The Regional Income Tax Agency lists Chagrin Falls at 1.85%, and Moreland Hills and Bentleyville at 1.00% each. The Central Collection Agency lists South Russell at 1.25% for 2026. Bainbridge, Auburn and Chagrin Falls Township have no municipal income tax.
These rates are general information as of their published dates, not tax, legal or financial advice. Please confirm your own situation with a tax professional.
Village Water, or a Private Well
Utilities split along these lines too, sometimes within a single village. South Russell's new-resident guide says the village's west end, parts of Bell Road and the East Washington Street commercial area get Chagrin Falls water. Some developments have their own systems, and the rest of the homes use private wells. The same guide says most residents are on the Geauga County sanitary sewer system.
The guide was posted in 2015, and it describes service areas street by street, not village-wide. So whether a house gets its water from the village or from a well depends on the parcel. On a property that may have a well, ask the listing side for the current water and sewer provider before you make an offer. That way the inspection plan covers the right systems.
Reading the Next Listing That Says Chagrin Falls
The postal name is a starting point. The community named on the county record is what places a home among its real comparable sales. A $540,000 house in South Russell, a $543,000 house in Bainbridge and a $532,500 house in the village trade in roughly the same range. A house in Bentleyville or Chagrin Falls Township sits in a different price band altogether, whatever the mailbox says. For the village itself, see our Chagrin Falls neighborhood page and our post on the village's recent restaurant changes.
If you're comparing listings with a Chagrin Falls address and want to know which community each one is in and which sales it should be measured against, the Smith Garofoli Group is glad to go through them with you. If you already own one and want to know which comparable sales apply to it, start with a home valuation or contact us.